29 to 75 conversion

Reef Aquarium & Tank Building Forum

Help Support Reef Aquarium & Tank Building Forum:

Airphotog

Love my Nikon
Joined
Nov 1, 2010
Messages
537
Location
Tacoma, WA
I am going to turn my 75 planted tank into a reef. I have quite a bit of rock that has been in a 29 and and also a sump circulating with heat and light in my garage. The sump has a chamber with medium size rubble with water running on it and another 30 or 40 pounds in it and a couple of Percs. First will I have much of a cycle? Next I am torn between sand or no sand. Any comments please.
 
I believe that anytime you take your rocks out for transfer and you give new surface area you will see a small cycle. Not like setting up a tank from fresh but you will get a small cycle. May not even be noticable. I have upgraded several tanks without a visual cycle (diatoms, and algaes) but parameter wise you can see a slight rise.
 
I believe that anytime you take your rocks out for transfer and you give new surface area you will see a small cycle. Not like setting up a tank from fresh but you will get a small cycle. May not even be noticable. I have upgraded several tanks without a visual cycle (diatoms, and algaes) but parameter wise you can see a slight rise.
+1. You'll have a mini cycle
 
It's been done I believe. The advantages and disadvantages for both are pretty well known and discussed, but if it becomes an issue for you in your upgrade I'm sure someone will delve into the subject.
 
YOu will see a bit of a cycle, but YOu can use a product like "The one and only" ?? anyway its a bacteria in a bottle product that will take up any N that you get from exposing the the rock. As per the sand its down to personal choice, both ways comes with pros and cons and both will need active husbandry to maintain for the long term success of the tank. With the no sand you will need to stay on top of detritus that falls out onto the tank floor, its pretty easy a you can control it fairly well with flow but you need to be actively removing it. With the sand its always becomes a matter of maintaining the top layer (reducing the load and keeping it airated) also at some point down the road (depending on bioload) you will need to deal with the end product that builds.

For me I hate the issues that sand brings to the game, BUT I do like the look of it, so I went with just a couple of inches and then maintained it by syphoning out as much detritus as I can so that the pressure on it is lessened.

On the rubble I find it to be counter productive, It tends to trap detritus and does not deal with it. If you keep that area in the sump clear the detritus is very easy to remove.


Mojo
 

Latest posts

Back
Top