I just checked TAP website and found that for 4 10"x10" square cut is around $22.00 and that is with them cutting them for you and not the scrap prices. This would be the nice cell cast stuff and with a nice clean edge too. They have all the special tooling necessary to get great results with plastics.
Here are some price ideas from TAP Plastics website.
Color Clear
Size 1/4" Thick, 10" Wide, 10" Long
Quantity 4
Cost $21.53
Color Clear
Size 1/4" Thick, 12" Wide, 12" Long
Quantity 4
Cost $31.00
Here is the TAP closest to your area,
710 9th Avenue North
Seattle, WA 98109
Free Parking across the street!
Please note: 9th Avenue closed due to construction
Call store for parking direction.
Open: Mon-Fri 8:30 to 6, Sat 9 to 5.