FOTW ~Zanclus cornutus~

Reef Aquarium & Tank Building Forum

Help Support Reef Aquarium & Tank Building Forum:

NaH2O

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 25, 2004
Messages
8,568
Hey everyone! This weeks installment of Fish of The Week, is Zanclus cornutus, also known as the Moorish Idol. They are sometimes seen for sale, and IMO should be left out in the ocean, or else they will likely parish.

This species is all by itself in the genus Zanclus, and is a very recognizable fish. Growing to approximately 6-10 inches, a distinguishing characteristic is the long filament on the dorsal fin. They also have a prominent spine in front of their eyes, a long tubular snout and bristle-like teeth, which is used to eat sponges and coralline growth out of the crevices in the reef. Damage to the mouth, like in bristle-tooth tangs, will likely lead to death. They are found in the Indo-Pacific: East Africa to Rapa and Ducie Islands, north to southern Japan and the Hawaiian Islands, south to the Lord Howe Island; throughout Micronesia. Eastern Pacific: southern Gulf of California to Peru. They inhabit turbid inner lagoons, reef flats, and clear seaward rocky and coral reefs. Often Moorish Idols are seen alone or in small groups of 2-3, sometimes found in large shoals.

A sad fact for this beautiful fish, is they often do not survive in the aquarium, and IMO, should not be purchased. Aside from capture and shipping stress, the Moorish Idol has very specific dietary needs. Despite some experienced aquarists best efforts, an eating Moorish Idol can die. It has been hypothesized that there is something specific in the diet of this fish that isn't present in prepared foods, and the nutrition requirements aren't being fulfilled. Whatever the cause, these fish are not suited for aquarium life, IMO. Besides the difficulty in feeding and subsequent starvation, if purchased, the Moorish Idol should be provided a large aquarium with tons of swimming room, including a hiding place for it to dash in when threatened. The rock should be full of sponge and algae for better chance of survival.

Because of the poor survival of the Moorish Idol in captivity, I give it a big thumbs down for tank suitability. These guys are best left out in the wild for us to enjoy in their natural habitat, and I strongly discourage purchasing them.
 
Hi, Nikki!

Z. cornutus aka Moorish Idol (MI) is one of my favorite fish in my tank. I got it three months ago and he/she is doing great until now. Knocking the wood... many times... ;)

I have 250 g established tank along with a DSB refugium, 250 lb LR with plenty of various sponges on them. I never saw him eating those sponges though :doubt: The food I'm offering consists of O.S.I. marine pellets, Sera Granumarin pellets, Spirulina flakes, frozen artemia and bloodworms, occasionally my own home-made coral/fish food mix containing about 20 ingredients. My MI is the second best eater (after the 8" blue tang Paracanthurus hepatus) in my tank. Besides of eating prepared food he's always picking algae or whatever else from LR. So I'm still quite hopeful about the future. Knocking the wood again...

Before buying a MI it is absolutely necessary to be sure that it is really eating at your LFS. Even if is eating well, many experts say that after two months there will be a critical period, when MI may die without any visible to us reason. Only changes in the behavior of my MI I noticed after two and half months, when he stopped eating and didn't swam much around like earlier. But after two days everything turned back to good again :)

040824-010.jpg


Wearing a night-suite ;)
dsc01453.jpg


A slideshow of my Moorish Idol is available <<here>>

Henn
 
Albert,
I'm glad you have had success with your Idol, but I would have to agree with Nikki. If folks dont buy these delicate fish that most likely wont survive long, then the LFs will not purchase them from distributers and the fish wont be collected. Simple matter of supply and demand.
 
There are always exceptions to the rule. I have to say yours sure is pretty Albert. Like Nikki said it is a fish that has a dismal record of survival in our tanks. I dont know why. Thanks for sharing your experince with it. Have you kept a log on it? If you do, and others do. Over time we may be able to keep this fish long term in captivity. 10 years ago a lot of the corals and fish we keep today were impossible to keep. Based on that info, I think we will be able to keep others in the future. Just my opinions Steve
 
Wow!! Such a beautiful fish, and it is easy to see why hobbyists want them. I hope you continue to have good success with it <knocking on wood for you> - it is apparent that the size of your system and expertise will be beneficial to the MI's well being. I do want to comment again, that this fish is not for the majority of reefkeepers.

I enjoyed your slide show very much.
 
Yes, the Moorish Idol is a spectacular fish that tempts even the most conscientious aquarist. However, I agree that their survival rate in private aquariums in dismal at best. I have seen many of them that are voracious eaters and they die within months anyway. I also suspect that there is something missing in their diet that we cannot provide and they are very susceptible to any sort of stress. Success with this or any other species of fish is measured in years not months. IMO, anything less is ultimate failure and a waste of life. :(

Terry B
 
I dont see what to big deal is, I dont even really like them. I agree that they should be kept in the wild, and they were cool to see in hawaii, but I think they are ugly fish. Good luck with yours Albert, he looks pretty healthy.
 
BlennyBabe said:
I dont see what to big deal is, I dont even really like them. I agree that they should be kept in the wild, and they were cool to see in hawaii, but I think they are ugly fish.

Is there such a thing as an ugly fish?
I love em all! :D

Maui
 
Terry B said:
Success with this or any other species of fish is measured in years not months. IMO, anything less is ultimate failure and a waste of life. :(
One year and counting... ;)

dsc02892.jpg
 
I was helping a store owner in the U-District because his knowledge base was slim at best. He had a customer come in and ask to buy twenty Moorish Idols. We explained to him that this was a very difficult fish to keep. At this point he said he did not care about the surviveability of the fish and that they were for an "art" project. The owner proceded to bring in three or four of these beautiful animals per shipment. When I tried to discuss the problems I had with this situation he agreed that it was wrong to sacrifice the animals but refused to feel responsible. The customer had gone to the other stores in town but had been refused service when the project was explained. I no longer patronize stores in the U-District and go out of my way to give the sponsors of this board my money.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top