tamarindthai
Well-known member
i wondering the medication from nosickfish.com are really worth to buy and really work,,it is very expensive.please advise.
Last edited:
medication from nosickfish.com?
- Thread starter tamarindthai
- Start date
Help Support Reef Aquarium & Tank Building Forum:
Boomer
Well-known member
Unless Lee knows something I would say stay away. They are not telling you what is in the bottles. And one should not have to do a MSDS seach on their productsand I can not even find one NOT GOOD. And there are a number of bad reviews at least on some of their products on foums. And their price is out of this world and IMHO a hype
tamarindthai
Well-known member
thanks ,Boomer,,you made the point and i do have the bad experienced with them already
just for Lee openion.
just for Lee openion.
I can only add to Boomer's post that:
They would not tell me how to test that the medication was in the proper concentration.
I can perhaps agree to an inventor keeping the ingredients secret, but I do not add things to my aquarium for which I cannot test and determine how much of it is there. I'm too much the quantitative chemist for that.
Lastly, from what people in the know and in whom I trust (that know the difference between a 'cure' and fish developing immunity) have reported, it doesn't cure Marine Ich (Cryptocaryon irritans) infections.
There are many products that contain chemicals known to kill Marine Ich in laboratory experiments. But in actual applications to reefs and FOWLR systems they don't succeed as frequently nor as reliably as the 3 standard treatment methods.
For me, the unfortunate thing is the time and lives wasted in using something that won't work while the fish could have been saved using one of the known treatments.
Maybe someday. . .
They would not tell me how to test that the medication was in the proper concentration.
I can perhaps agree to an inventor keeping the ingredients secret, but I do not add things to my aquarium for which I cannot test and determine how much of it is there. I'm too much the quantitative chemist for that.
Lastly, from what people in the know and in whom I trust (that know the difference between a 'cure' and fish developing immunity) have reported, it doesn't cure Marine Ich (Cryptocaryon irritans) infections.
There are many products that contain chemicals known to kill Marine Ich in laboratory experiments. But in actual applications to reefs and FOWLR systems they don't succeed as frequently nor as reliably as the 3 standard treatment methods.
For me, the unfortunate thing is the time and lives wasted in using something that won't work while the fish could have been saved using one of the known treatments.
Maybe someday. . .
tamarindthai
Well-known member
from my bad experienced and mistaked by used unknown product from them,,,wiped out my whole tank of 12 fishes ,that the very expensive mistaked and from misleading product,,no more sickfish(.com) in my tank anymore because they all die,i will not buy or even try any more of nosickfish.com medication for sure,, ,,thanks for reponsed
from my
I can only add to Boomer's post that:
They would not tell me how to test that the medication was in the proper concentration.
I can perhaps agree to an inventor keeping the ingredients secret, but I do not add things to my aquarium for which I cannot test and determine how much of it is there. I'm too much the quantitative chemist for that.
Lastly, from what people in the know and in whom I trust (that know the difference between a 'cure' and fish developing immunity) have reported, it doesn't cure Marine Ich (Cryptocaryon irritans) infections.
There are many products that contain chemicals known to kill Marine Ich in laboratory experiments. But in actual applications to reefs and FOWLR systems they don't succeed as frequently nor as reliably as the 3 standard treatment methods.
For me, the unfortunate thing is the time and lives wasted in using something that won't work while the fish could have been saved using one of the known treatments.
Maybe someday. . .
from my
Last edited:
To be blunt .. this is a questionable outfit where the officers/owners have been caught placing phony threads on two salt water forums that I have visited. The whole world has been anxiously awaiting a credible reef safe ich medication and anyone who comes up with one is not going to have to market that way.
