It could also have to do with the age and model of the IceCap ballasts and the age of each bulb. The XM bulb I used was not as old as the Radium bulb I used. So many different variables.
I run reeflux 10K on the main tank with actinics on each end of the light cycle and am very happy with growth and color. I am looking for a very blue solution for the frag tank which is a 30 gallon. I do not want to run actinics in additon to the MH's. I do not want growth just color. I am starting to think I should just go T5 but 4 short T5's cost more than a single MH. Hopefully somebody has a used up radium or xm 20K 250W I could borrow to see if there is any difference.
I have a XM 20k and a Radium bulb you could borrow.
But if you are dead set against using VHO actinic, I don't think you will find the amount of blue it sounds like you are looking for.
Maybe T5 is the way