Should I start over????

Reef Aquarium & Tank Building Forum

Help Support Reef Aquarium & Tank Building Forum:

Yes, I made a mistake. It is 7 fish. Not much for a 90 gal, but definately too soon. I guess I got caught up on the idea that if I had 0 ammonia and 0 nitrite that my tank was ready. But like they say, first time is practice or trial and the second, a charm.
 
What do you guys think about leaving in a clean-up crew in the tank during this time. I ran out to the beach last weekend and got me some more coral banded shrimps and a brittle star. The brittle star, even though it's only 1, keeps my substrate really clean so I'm thinking on getting aother one. I also, have 5 blue hermit crabs, which I can easily go back and get more. I can practically sit in my car and grab as many as I want.
 
Angelscrx said:
So would you say a tank that has been cycled and running for 6 months and the params, temp, lighting etc were all balanced, still add corals slowly huh? I agree, I would hate to lose 5 grand because I was in a rush to get my slice of ocean.
Personally, I would add the corals slowly, if only for practical reasons. It takes time to get corals into a tank - placing, gluing (or tieing), re-placing when it doesn't look right, etc.

Yes, I did one of those 10-coral packages. Took me hours to get them all in the tank. I set up a holding tank (my Q-tank) just to have someplace to put them so they weren't in the way while I was placing the individual corals in the tank.

Also, by adding the corals slowly, you can see (and possibly modify) what kind of environment your tank is evolving into. You can observe where the high-flow, high-light places really are (and the high-light but not as much flow as you thought places are as well). If the tank is "filled" all at once, it is very difficult to move unhappy corals into better places. (something might already be there).

To me, the biggest frustration in this hobby/obsession is that when you mailorder a coral, you pay as much for shipping as for the coral. When you order lots of corals to minimize the shipping/coral, you end up with more corals than you really want to be putting in at once. I went through a period where I cruised the LFS's looking for just the right coral (that I could have easily gotten mailorder, but did not want to pay the shipping for). Still do, but not as often as I used to.

Of course, if you have lots of experience with reef tanks, you can anticipate things a lot better, and fill you tank up more quickly. But for hobbyists with only a few years of experience, I am in favor of going slowly.
(In your case, if you are aching to spend $5k this week, I'll come over and advise you on coral placement. I'll also hold any corals for a few years for you if necessary, until we agree exactly where they should go! :) )
 
krish75 said:
What do you guys think about leaving in a clean-up crew in the tank during this time. I ran out to the beach last weekend and got me some more coral banded shrimps and a brittle star. The brittle star, even though it's only 1, keeps my substrate really clean so I'm thinking on getting aother one. I also, have 5 blue hermit crabs, which I can easily go back and get more. I can practically sit in my car and grab as many as I want.

That's it! Rub it in! Make us cold-climate folks really feel our misery, especially in the Winter season!

I think it would be a good idea to keep some life in the tank (your clean-up crew), just to keep your bacteria population going. You may need to feed them a bit, though.
As far as your ability to easily get some of your animals from the beach - remember, you may be significantly changing the environment for some of these animals (for example, no beach for the hermits to run across), and in the future you could be forcing animals from different environments into close proximity in your tank, resulting in some unexpected predator/victim situations.
 
i had cyano in my tank too and used a chemical to get rid of it. it was safe for inverts and corals. it didn't harm anything (not even the live rock, purpletip, leathers, mushrooms, coraline or anything) and got rid of the cyano. it's called chemi-clean. i am sure that you can find it in your lfs. i don't usually like to add chemicals to my tank to solve problems but i delt with it for a long time (months and months) and it just wouldn't go away no matter what i did. this finally got rid of it. i wouldn't start over if i was you, you have to get through the natural cycle first. give it a year or so.
good luck!
 
You sit in your car and grab hermits. LOL I had a vison of you driving down the beach door open head hanging down over the sand snatching crabs and tossing into the back seat. LOL Must be nice, you know people pay 5.99 each for good sized ones around here. LOL
If it were my tank I would remove the bioballs, and clean the cannister filter every two weeks. Remove the crushed coral and dive out there and bring you back some sand. LOL I wish I could. at 29.99 a bag for 20lbs which most is water. LOL Hook up on lots of flow and everything will work out. HTH Steve
 

Latest posts

Back
Top