urgent question about dry rock!!!

Reef Aquarium & Tank Building Forum

Help Support Reef Aquarium & Tank Building Forum:

cindywhip

Active member
Joined
Feb 24, 2009
Messages
27
Location
maryland
Hi Guys, I used dry base rock for setting up another tank and now I am worried that it will cause problems down the road when it starts to become live rock will it??? I have always only bought cured live rock but I was a little short on funds so I used dry base rock and set cured live on top of it..should I remove the dry rock??????:(
 
I have 5 chromis 2 snails and a hermit the water tests perfect but I'm afraid when this base rock begins to cure it may cause problems? I'm just not sure my gut says take it out...
 
All true, but the chromises are tough nevertheless and snails can take quite a lot too.
I wouldn't sweat it unless as sid pointed out, if it was covered in dry algae, etc.

Seachem Stability is not a bad product, but with any live rock, just a waste of money similar to most bottled products. Pet stores enjoying selling "time in a bottle"
 
Last edited:
yeah this base rock was about 4 chunks a bit smaller than a football and dry as a bone literally like chaulk when I got it home I rinced it thoughly in R/O water and began setting the tank up thats been 3 weeks ago all the test have come out perfect so I was planning on switching the cuc clowns and other fish to this tank this weekend provided the water still checks out. than suddenly I thought s*** what have I done ? now I'm worried...
 
A good way to check to see if your rock is populated with bacteria, pull the fish and snails if possible. If not, don't continue with my directions. It sounds like it is considering you have more fish that you plan on moving into the tank with the dry rock. Anyway, pull out everything that is alive and go to the grocery store and get yourself some ammonia. It's like a buck a bottle. Just get the plain old stuff with no coloring or fragrance. Use about 1/4 tsp per 20g of water. Test to make sure you're getting some sort of reading after letting the tank mix around. Once you get a reading of ammonia, 1-2ppm, wait a good 8-12 hours and check again. If the ammonia level hasn't fallen, your rock is not populated. If it has, check your trites. If you have no trites, your rock should be cycled. Add the fish you took out and then slowly add the rest of your fish over the next week or 2 depending on how many and how large they are.

This is basically a fish less cycling method used in freshwater tanks, but I know it works in saltwater as well.

Your tank should already be cycled if you've had the rock with fish in the tank for a good 3 weeks. Another member here named Myteemouse just went through cycling some dead rock that he had. It took him about 2 weeks.
 
Last edited:
Thank's for all the great advise! I will be keeping a close eye on the tank. I did add new live rock last night I new I was going to need more anyway .I also left the dry rock in there.the new live rock I bought has been cured for 3 months and is covered in coraline alge $$. this morning all the fish are active and doing good I will test the water later today just to make sure nothing has changed. Thanks again Cindy
 

Latest posts

Back
Top