I don't mind anyone disagreeing with me, in fact, I think the original poster needs to see/"hear" it. I too am going on experience, and in my opinion, the fewer moving parts, the better. I have seen flooded livingrooms with both, most of which are the result of user error. Both have their benefits and limitations, that really is the point (as you made, and as I feel saltwater teen fails to perhaps see). I like my simple design because it is much more cost effective, one less plug I need, and has (had) never caused any problems. Others like their CPR. No worries, I just wanted to throw out other opinions...
Also, as is the case with the internet, you get all sorts of people. I don't consider the PS2 basher to be very credible, although the credibility of anyone is questionable on these boards... However, do a search on RC, RAG, RF, RS, etc... and you will see that plenty of people have had their difficulties.
No need to apologize for having a different opinion, that is what makes the boards so beneficial...
Take er easy
Scott T.